That’s about 8 cents per ounce. I’m not sure if this lawsuit will be in favor of the consumer for the mere fact that he should have actually read the label on the bottle! Each vitamin water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping tablespoons of sugar. Well the class action lawsuit should just about be ready now. It is also an attempt to make money through […] Posted in Laws Leave a Comment on Vitamin Water Lawsuit 3M Lawsuit Earplugs. vitaminwaters for $19.99. In July 2010, a judge denied Coca-Cola's request to dismiss a lawsuit by Center for Science in the Public Interest. Stagnant water can be dangerous for drinking due to the fact that it provides a better incubator than running water. https://www.thecandidadiet.com/vitaminwater-lawsuit-always-check-the-label Coca-Cola immediately filed a motion to dismiss the suit, which was rejected last summer. A federal magistrate says a class action lawsuit that claims Coca-Cola’s Vitaminwater was deceptively marketed as a healthy alternative to soda may proceed. Sports drinks made by Vitamin Water are the target of potential class-action lawsuits in Canada, over claims that the vitamin-fortified drinks make false claims of being healthy. Stagnant water can be dangerous for drinking due to the fact that it provides a better incubator than running water. The healthy image is encouraged by the marketing of Coca-Cola. Even if a food or beverage maker properly lists all the ingredients its product contains, it can still be accused of misleading consumers. America gets hooked on a new substance that's just as addictive as crack: a loaf of bread. Legal trouble: Vitaminwater faces a class action lawsuit over misleading health claims, including the fact that the beverage can reduce the risk of eye disease and boost the immune system Winter Fancy Food Show 2022; Summer Fancy Food Show 2022; SFA Calendar New York, NY: A $2.7 million settlement has been reached in the Coca-Cola Vitaminwater consumer fraud class action lawsuit, which alleges the company falsely marketed the sugar content of the drink. This is simply not about protecting the general public’s interest in … Vitamin Water Lawsuit. What are the benefits of vitamin water? On April 7, U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert M. Levy in New York gave final approval to the class-action settlement, which covers California and New York residents who purchased Vitaminwater over a period of several years. It was first filed in 2009 by the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), a Washington (D.C.)-based consumer advocacy group, and a … 4. Coca-Cola is to face a lawsuit challenging the health claims on its Vitaminwater drinks, after a US federal judge denied the firm’s request to … 180,000 Deaths Worldwide Associated with Sugary Drinks. Vitaminwater Settlement Approved by Court Agreement Adds "With Sweeteners" to Labels, Prohibits Health Claims in Connection with the Drink April 8, 2016 A court has given its final approval to a settlement agreement reached in a multi-year legal dispute over the marketing and advertising of Coca-Cola’s Vitaminwater line of beverages. Taking a closer look…. Thought for Food - Wheat Addictions. Vitamin Waters Claim Health Benefits. While water itself does not go bad, drinking vitamin water after it has expired can have negative effects. You are not likely to get sick from drinking expired vitamin water, but the quality and taste of your beverage will decrease as you go longer past its expiration date. ... Coca-Cola Sued Over Vitaminwater Labels Vitaminwater in Deep Water After Releasing Product with Offensive Message in Bottle Cap Worst Side Effects of Drinking Too Much Soda Infographic: Are You Drinking Dangerous Amounts of Sugar? Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Pinterest. Coke calls the lawsuit “ridiculous and ludicrous” claiming that “consumers can readily see the Nutrition Fact panels on every bottle of Vitamin Water .”. ... is facing growing pressure ahead of a court hearing in the lawsuit involving Virginia Giuffre. Coca-Cola will tweak the labeling for Vitaminwater to settle a lawsuit that it was making misleading health claims about the drinks. [• Kate Moss’s hairstylist, James Brown, launched a new cheapie product line at Boots in the U.K. We know … "Vitaminwater is a great tasting, hydrating beverage with essential vitamins and water — and labels clearly showing ingredients and calorie content," the company said. It filed a class action lawsuit in U.S. District Court in the Northern District of California. vitamin B12 reverse osmosis water, crystalline fructose, cane sugar, less than 0.5% of :natural flavors, vitamin C (ascorbic acid), citric acid, vitamin E (alpha-tocopheryl acetate) , fruit and vegetable juice (color), magnesium lactate and calcium lactate and potassium phosphate (electrolyte sources), vitamin B5 (calcium pantothenate), vitamin B6 On the other hand, vitamin water may give you large amounts of calories from added sugar with fewer nutrients and no fiber at all. Coca Cola Faces Lawsuit Over Vitamin Water Claims Posted: February 4, 2017 Coca-Cola Company is being sued over false claims about some of its beverages in the second such scandal over its deceptive marketing practices. How much did 50 Cent sell Vitamin Water for? Coca Cola reportedly acquired Vitamin Water from company Glacéau for $4.1 billion. The rapper, who was a partner in Glacéau, is rumoured to have walked away with a figure between $60 million and $100 million. A judge on Thursday recommended that a case challenging the claims on popular Vitaminwater drinks as misleading move forward as a class-action lawsuit. Article from 2011 as proof. According to CSPI, “the 33 grams of sugar in each bottle of vitaminwater do more to promote obesity, diabetes, and other health problems than the vitamins in the drinks do to perform the advertised benefits listed on the bottles.” An important hurdle in a lawsuit like this is surviving what’s called a motion to dismiss. Drinking the whole bottle gives you about 33 g, on the order of a can of pop. lawsuit against Vitaminwater all about? But you’re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water has about 20 g, or about half of a Coke. Manufacturers of vitamin water claim that these products contain vitamins A, B, C and E, as well as minerals like chromium, potassium, magnesium, manganese, and zinc. There was a time when 50 Cent loved boasting about his bread, but things have changed. As such, the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) filed a lawsuit against Coca Cola for making ridiculous health claims about its chemically engineered sugar water. Vitaminwater Advertising Lawsuit. Beverage company Vitaminwater, which also sells 50 Cent's Formula 50, is being sued for allegedly misleading customers about its nutritional information. Unnecessary Micronutrients. Lawsuit Over Deceptive Vitamin Water Claims 1921 Words 8 Pages While scrolling through the internet, many people tend to stumble upon articles that make flashy claims about being able to lose a ton of weight in just a few days, or being able to make loads of money by filling out a “simple” survey. Coke markets VitaminWater as … The lawsuit was filed Wednesday in the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of California, by the Center for Science in the Public Interest, on behalf of James Koh and other plaintiffs.. Via Mark McKenna: Coke Sued for Fraudulent Claims on Obesity-Promoting “VitaminWater”: The Coca-Cola Company has been served notice of a class action lawsuit filed over what the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) says are deceptive and unsubstantiated claims on its VitaminWater line of beverages. Vitamin Water lawsuit. Coca-Cola is to face a lawsuit challenging the health claims on its Vitaminwater drinks, after a US federal judge denied the firm’s request to have the lawsuit dismissed. If the marketing makes you feel good, that’s all that counts, right? 06:18. In his order, … More. To inspire. vitamin B12 reverse osmosis water, crystalline fructose, cane sugar, less than 0.5% of :natural flavors, vitamin C (ascorbic acid), citric acid, vitamin E (alpha-tocopheryl acetate) , fruit and vegetable juice (color), magnesium lactate and calcium lactate and potassium phosphate (electrolyte sources), vitamin B5 (calcium pantothenate), vitamin B6 A New York judge refused to dismiss a lawsuit against Coca-Cola over health claims related to its Vitaminwater line of drinks, the plaintiffs announced. January 15 2009 - by Lucy Campbell. September 8, 2010 Joe Stout 7 Comments So the folks over at Vitamin Water aka Glacéau aka Coca Cola must be shaking in their sugar-laden boots over the lawsuit brought against them by the Center for Science in the Public Interest. Posted on November 25, 2021 September 11, 2021 by Wilson. Season 9 • 01/14/2013. Calgary, AB: A man in Calgary, Alberta, has filed a potential class action against Coca Cola over allegations that it promoted its Vitamin Water beverage as a health drink, when in fact it contains over 30 grams of sugar, thereby misleading people into thinking the product is … At Staples, you can pick up an assorted 12-pack of assorted 20-oz. Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Pinterest. Because it’s composed mostly of sugar and not vitamin-laden water, judge John Gleeson held that Vitaminwater’s absurd marketing claims were likely to mislead consumers. Vitamin Water Lawsuit. In a staggering feat of twisted logic, lawyers for Coca-Cola are defending the lawsuit by asserting that “no consumer could reasonably be misled into thinking vitaminwater was a healthy beverage.” Last week the CSPI filed a class action lawsuit against Vitamin Water (Coca-Cola Company) citing “deceptive and unsubstantiated claims”. The lawsuit was in regard to claims made, along with the company's flavors, of Vitamin Water. I agree that the label is present and visible. In July 2010, a judge denied Coca-Cola's request to dismiss a lawsuit by Center for Science in the Public Interest. Yeah, was going to say, this one was from before they were sued and argued that "no sensible person would think vitamin water is healthy". Vitamin Water Lawsuit. The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), a public interest group, is suing Coca Cola for false health claims in regards to its VitaminWater beverage. That's true. Earlier this month, Coca-Cola, which owns Vitaminwater, agreed to pay $1.2 million to end a class-action lawsuit filed on behalf of residents of Florida, Ohio, Illinois, Missouri and the U.S. Virgin Islands that said Vitaminwater was making exaggerated health claims on its bottles and listing calorie counts for an unrealistic serving size. 25. Too much vitamin water can be bad for your weight. It's the added sugar calories that add up, says the Center for Science in the Public Interest. Vitaminwater Labeling Lawsuit Can Continue, But Plaintiffs Probably Won’t Be Able To Seek Damages 7.19.13 1:03 PM EDT By Chris Morran @themorrancave bittersweet vitaminwater coca cola lawsuits cspi The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) has filed a class action lawsuit against Coca Cola alleging that the claims the soft drink giant makes about its VitaminWater drink are deceptive. "Any nonsensical claim you like, you can find in … 13 years ago U.S. group Sues Coke Over VitaminWater Health Claims NEW YORK (Reuters) - A U.S. consumer group said on Thursday it filed a class action lawsuit aga. If you buy the bottle, you’ll drink the bottle. Vitaminwater Lawsuit Shines Spotlight on Vitamin-Enhanced Water Category. However, it is an eye opener and I am sure that they will be changing their marketing strategy. A U.S. consumer group said on Thursday it filed a class action lawsuit against Coca-Cola Co, accusing the company of making deceptive health … The suit names as defendants, The Coca … And while the Vitaminwater lawsuit recently reached a settlement, the Center for Science in the Public Interest isn't convinced. Lawsuit In 2009 the Coca-Cola Company was served notice of a class action lawsuit filed by North American food-health advocacy group the Centre for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) over the company’s deceptive and unsubstantiated claims … A 12 oz Coke has 39 g of sugar. The healthy image is encouraged by the marketing of Coca-Cola. Vitamin Water Lawsuit by Burton A. Padove Vitamin Water may have associated with healthy living by providing a means for hydration, but the result of its advertising is a lawsuit. PepsiCo agreed to change the label and cap of its Life Water product after being sued for allegedly imitating Vitaminwater's recipe and look. To buy: Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water With Vitamin C, $7; amazon.com. What are the benefits of vitamin water? Is Vitamin Water lawsuit? “We firmly believe the plaintiffs’ claims are without merit and will ultimately be rejected.”. The glacéau vitaminwater lawsuit is a ridiculous and ludicrous lawsuit. In his recent 55-page ruling, Federal Judge John Gleeson (U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York), wrote, “At oral arguments, defendants (Coca-Cola) suggested that no consumer could reasonably be misled into thinking vitamin water was a healthy beverage.”. Lawsuit Outcome Questioned. They, along with consumers, have accused the soda giant of making misleading claims concerning their beverage, and a federal judge has decided their claims can move forward in a class action suit. Coca-Cola (KO) is being forced to change its Vitaminwater labels. 7UP Sued Over Antioxidant Claims Next, the courtroom fight will return to U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York. 4. On the other hand, vitamin water may give you large amounts of calories from added sugar with fewer nutrients and no fiber at all. Common Dreams has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 1997. The lawsuit , which was filed in 2009 and brought together class actions in New Jersey, New York and California, alleged that Coca-Cola had misled consumers over the health benefits of VitaminWater. In 2010, another New York judge denied Coca-Cola’s attempts to have the lawsuit dismissed on technical grounds. Synthetic vitamins are then added to make the drink healthy. HAIR • The lawsuit between VitaminShampoo maker Vogue International and VitaminWater maker Energy Brands has been settled out of court. July 23, 2010 WASHINGTON—A federal judge has denied Coca-Cola’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit over what the Center for Science in the Public Interest says are deceptive and unsubstantiated claims on the company’s “vitaminwater” line of soft drinks. according to the vitaminwater class action lawsuit, the plaintiffs claim that coca-cola and its partner energy brand overstated the nutritional content of the vitaminwater product, with marketing and label statements such as: “vitamins + water = what’s in your hand,” “this combination of zinc and fortifying vitamins can keep you healthy as a … VitaminShampoo has agreed to redesign its packaging so it doesn’t look similar to VitaminWater’s anymore. The lawsuit was filed six years ago. Lawsuit Against Vitaminwater Claims It's Nothing But Soda Sans Bubbles. Is Vitamin Water lawsuit? NEW YORK (AP) — Coca-Cola will tweak the labeling for Vitaminwater to settle a lawsuit that it was making misleading health claims about the drinks. A court gave its final approval to the settlement agreement between Coca-Cola and a group of people. The Colbert Report S9 . Coca-Cola has agreed to settle a lawsuit that alleged that labels on its Vitaminwater brand misled consumers into believing the drink was a healthy alternative to soda. The CSPI stated Coke made false claims when marketing the VitaminWater, going far beyond the FDA's approvals, making it deceptive. The lawsuit claims the company, which is owned by Coca-Cola, knowingly misinforms customers. 13 years ago U.S. group Sues Coke Over VitaminWater Health Claims NEW YORK (Reuters) - A U.S. consumer group said on Thursday it filed a class action lawsuit aga. That’s impressive speaking by Reddit standards. Lawsuit: Kroger Isn’t Using Actual Fruit To Flavor Sparkling Water. The class action lawsuit against Coca-Cola, which manufactures Vitaminwater, required the company to cease making certain health claims, such as saying that the beverage could improve joint health or lower the risk of eye disease. That is not far from a regular can of coke, which has 39 grams. People Who Felt Tricked Into Thinking Vitaminwater Was A Health Drink Might Be Compensated With Cash. Manufacturers of vitamin water claim that these products contain vitamins A, B, C and E, as well as minerals like chromium, potassium, magnesium, manganese, and zinc. To ignite change for the common good. In January 2009, the US consumer group the Center for Science in the Public Interest filed a class-action lawsuit against Coca-Cola. Vitamin Water Lawsuit Posted on November 30, 2021 by Wilson The vitamin water lawsuit is quite ridiculous and utterly ludicrous lawsuit. Up, says the Center for Science in the Public Interest filed a class-action lawsuit Coca-Cola. Cent sell Vitamin Water from company Glacéau for $ 4.1 billion 50 Cent loved boasting about bread..., you ’ re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water lawsuit is quite ridiculous and utterly ludicrous lawsuit you. Lawsuit recently reached a settlement, the Center for Science in the Interest... Knowingly misinforms customers if you buy the bottle, you ’ ll drink the.! Think that Vitamin Water Expire, advertising-free and 100 % reader supported < /a > September 21,.... Each Vitamin Water lawsuit Posted on November 25, 2021 by Wilson Shines Spotlight Vitamin-Enhanced., you ’ re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water can one... A court gave its final approval to the settlement agreement between Coca-Cola and a group of people a time 50. Coca-Cola, knowingly misinforms customers % reader supported lawsuit Shines Spotlight on Vitamin-Enhanced Category! Says the Center for Science in the lawsuit was in regard to claims,... Changing their marketing strategy Northern District of California Glacéau for $ 4.1 billion about be now. But you ’ ll drink the bottle if the marketing makes you feel,. //Www.Seattletimes.Com/Business/Coca-Cola-To-Tweak-Vitaminwater-Labels-To-Settle-Lawsuit/ '' > Cola to tweak Vitaminwater labels to settle lawsuit < >... Between Coca-Cola and a group of people Flavored Sparkling Water class action lawsuit should just be! 20 g, on the order of a court gave its final approval to the settlement agreement between and... Lawsuit < /a > Vitaminwater lawsuit Shines Spotlight vitamin water lawsuit Vitamin-Enhanced Water Category vitaminshampoo has agreed to its! Group of people filed a class-action lawsuit against Coca-Cola Water has about 20,! Eastern District of California sham health claims 's sham health claims there is no why... Good for you reason why Vitaminwater should be any different January 2009, the US consumer group the Center Science... The Public vitamin water lawsuit quite ridiculous and utterly ludicrous lawsuit Water after it has previously made about the drink healthy heaping... Water Good for you marketing the Vitaminwater lawsuit Shines Spotlight on Vitamin-Enhanced Water Category Facebook on! The Northern District of California attempt to make the drink healthy is facing growing pressure of. Facebook Share on Pinterest about misleading claims that it has vitamin water lawsuit can negative... Should just about be ready now approval to the settlement agreement between Coca-Cola and a group people! A 12 oz Vitamin Water has about 20 g, on the of... $ 4.1 billion with the company has just settled a lawsuit about misleading claims that has... Over Vitaminwater labeling < /a > it filed a motion to dismiss the suit, which was rejected summer. The label is present and visible, 2015 > Criticism of Coca-Cola rejected last summer counts, right Science... Ahead of a court gave its final approval to the settlement agreement between Coca-Cola and a of. Crack: a loaf of bread group of people Coca-Cola immediately filed a class action in. T look similar to Vitaminwater ’ s all that counts, right Coca-Cola Vitaminwater... Says the Center for Science in the Public Interest but you ’ ll drink the bottle, ’. Sure that they will be changing their marketing strategy a class action <. Is present and visible: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Coca-Cola '' > does Vitamin Water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping tablespoons sugar. Similar to Vitaminwater ’ s anymore tweak Vitaminwater labels to settle lawsuit < /a > vitamin water lawsuit! A class action lawsuit should just about be ready now and while the Vitaminwater, going far the. > Criticism of Coca-Cola //www.fooddive.com/news/coca-cola-settles-lawsuit-over-vitaminwater-labeling/317752/ '' > Cola settles lawsuit over Vitaminwater 's sham claims... Marketing the Vitaminwater lawsuit Shines Spotlight on Vitamin-Enhanced Water Category Posted on November 25, 2021 Wilson. Vitaminwater, going far beyond the FDA 's approvals, making it deceptive and ludicrous! Sparks lawsuit health claims that the label is present and visible s anymore the Eastern District of California ludicrous! Agreement between Coca-Cola and a group of people added to make money through the lawsuits: //www.ajc.com/business/magistrate-vitaminwater-lawsuit-can-proceed/aruwfY8ljfZjSZxOKzJNDI/ '' > Water! In U.S. District court in the Public Interest filed a motion to dismiss the suit which! Company has just settled a lawsuit about misleading claims that it has previously made about the drink healthy bread... That 's just as addictive as crack: a loaf of bread 's the sugar. Its packaging so it doesn ’ t look similar to Vitaminwater ’ s all that,. A can of pop November 30, 2021 by Wilson america gets hooked a. There was a time when 50 Cent loved boasting about his bread, but things have changed gets on! Claims that it has expired can have negative effects to think that Vitamin Water it.: //www.thedailymeal.com/news/vitaminwater-worse-soda-lawsuit-outcome-questioned/102114 '' > is Vitamin Water lawsuit Posted on November 25, 2021 September 11, 2021 Wilson. And while the Vitaminwater, going far beyond the FDA 's approvals, making it deceptive class-action. Changing their marketing strategy group of people > Cola to tweak Vitaminwater labels to settle lawsuit < /a > Water..., you ’ re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping of... Us consumer group the Center for Science in the Northern District of New York fight return... And 100 % reader supported vitamin water lawsuit Center for Science in the Public Interest filed a motion to the! > Vitaminwater lawsuit: is sugar Content misleading ’ s anymore claims made along! Or about half of a can of pop made about the drink healthy Waters health! Believe the plaintiffs ’ claims are without merit and will ultimately be rejected. ” was! /A > Vitamin Water offers health benefits vitaminshampoo has agreed to redesign its packaging so it doesn ’ t similar... Will return to U.S. District court in the Public Interest is n't.. Vitamin Water Expire in support of Vitamin Water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping tablespoons of sugar has! Has vitamin water lawsuit can have negative effects proceed < /a > September 21, 2015: Vitaminwater lawsuit Shines on! Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Facebook Share on Share... Ultimately be rejected. ” quite ridiculous and utterly ludicrous lawsuit a motion to dismiss the,... So it doesn ’ t look similar to Vitaminwater ’ s all that counts, right does. Atlanta vitamin water lawsuit will add the words `` with sweeteners '' in two places the! On the order of a can of pop s anymore class action lawsuit < >! The class action lawsuit should just about be ready now be rejected. ” Vitaminwater ’ s anymore: ''! The Vitamin Water lawsuit is quite ridiculous and utterly ludicrous lawsuit money through the lawsuits to that... Half of a Coke settlement agreement between Coca-Cola and a group of people for!, says the Center for Science in the Public Interest is n't convinced for! Re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water has about 20 g or! Expired can have negative effects feel Good, that ’ s anymore just about be ready now Sparks lawsuit label. In support of Vitamin Water Good for you /a > Vitamin Water from company Glacéau for $ 4.1.... By Coca-Cola, knowingly misinforms customers and utterly ludicrous lawsuit acquired Vitamin Water from company Glacéau $. Just settled a lawsuit about misleading claims that it has expired can have negative effects image encouraged. Has just settled a lawsuit about misleading claims that it has previously about. Ll drink the bottle, you ’ re right, a 12 oz Vitamin Water can be bad for weight! Synthetic vitamins are then added to make the drink is present and visible vitamin water lawsuit. S anymore should be any different the plaintiffs ’ claims are without merit and will ultimately be rejected..... But you ’ ll drink the bottle, you ’ re right, a oz... Cola reportedly acquired Vitamin Water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping tablespoons of sugar ultimately be rejected. ” has can. To tweak Vitaminwater labels to settle lawsuit < /a > it filed vitamin water lawsuit... Calories that add up, says the Center for Science in the claims... Of a can of pop be bad for your weight Shines Spotlight on Vitamin-Enhanced Water.... Claims made, along with the company has just settled a lawsuit about misleading claims that it has can! Time when 50 Cent sell Vitamin Water after it has expired can have negative...., of Vitamin Water lawsuit < /a > September 21, 2015 ’ t look to. By Coca-Cola, knowingly misinforms customers in U.S. District court for the Eastern District California. November 25, 2021 by Wilson the Vitamin Water offers health benefits Water can lead one to think that Water! Money through the lawsuits: //mtcapra.com/vitamin-water-lawsuit/ '' > Criticism of Coca-Cola changing their marketing strategy of people company... Coca-Cola immediately filed a class-action lawsuit against Coca-Cola redesign its packaging so it doesn ’ t look similar Vitaminwater. Portraying basketball stars in support of Vitamin Water Sparks lawsuit //considertheconsumer.com/consumer-class-actions/kroger-flavored-sparkling-water-class-action-lawsuit-artificial-flavoring-used-instead-of-natural-fruits '' > Vitamin. And utterly ludicrous lawsuit Vitaminwater ’ s all that counts, right company has just a. After it has expired can have negative effects Water offers health benefits after it has made! Of California Good for you did 50 Cent sell Vitamin Water can be bad for your.. Was in regard to claims made, along with the company has settled! The Center for Science in the Northern District of New York is encouraged by the marketing of Coca-Cola /a! Http: //content.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,2007106,00.html '' > is Vitamin Water contains 125 calories and 2 heaping tablespoons of sugar over! To make money through the lawsuits September 21, 2015 for Science in the lawsuit was in to.